Before Sherron Watkins found herself on the cover of Time, she was just an average citizen like anyone else. WHEN ENRON WAS RIDING HIGH, in the fall of 1995, an accountant named Sherron Watkins competed in a tournament that her boss, Andy Fastow, had devised, a contest he . He said he received complaints about the work of my group, specifically my group acted more like cops, preventing people from executing transactions instead of helping them.. The problem with innovation is the dark side of pushing your employees that much, says Watkins, who spoke at UNC Kenan-Flagler as part of the Deans Speaker Series. ", TEA could take over Houston ISD next week, Mayor Sylvester Turner says, What happened to the Luby's sign on Westheimer? The SEC said in its 2020 annual report to Congress that about 68% of its award recipients to date were current or former insiders of the company involved. Following her report of Enrons use of complicated off-balance-sheet vehicles to mask hundreds of millions of dollars in losses, Ms. Watkins was lauded and even chosen as one of Times Persons of the Year in 2002, alongside two other whistleblowers. She joined Enron in 1993, and departed in November 2002. On Thursday, February 19, famed Enron whistleblower Sherron S. Watkins outlined for Samford University students the ethical failures underlying her former employer's spectacular collapse. 1612 K St. NW, Suite #1100 She says she would have taken her concerns outside the company because she was naive to believe that the top executives would do the right thing. In a company that listed core values of respect, integrity, communication and excellence, success blinded executives and led them into committing fraud. Where was the Dayton peace agreement signed? She joined Enron in 1993, and departed in November 2002. She even proposed specific steps for Enron to follow if the company hoped to get out of this mess. Were such a crooked company., That message, she said, slapped him in the face more than anything else., She said she did most of the talking. Sherron recognized that students were being shortchanged by this situation, and she told her uncles about it. Watkins published a book in 2004 about her role in uncovering the Enron Scandal and actively participated in Government Accountability Projects American Whistleblower Tour. Nonetheless, Ms. Watkins describes herself as grossly underemployed, adding that she has struggled to find another job in the corporate world or long-term stable employment, including opportunities to teach. Since then, Watkins has been giving speeches at colleges and management congresses. More from my conversation with her: @KHOU at 10:00 #khou11 pic.twitter.com/kmqkZ0td5M. Ms. Watkins first wrote her one-page fraud complaint anonymously and placed it in an employee dropbox in August 2001, but she decided to identify herself the next day and meet with You cant change the value system unless youre the leader. the Enron Corp. executive who warned management about fraud, said not having confidentiality and protection for whistleblowers can have a cost. In late 2001 the news was made public that many top executives at Enron were corrupt and dishonest. But a whistle-blower is. HOUSTON, Texas Enrons energy empire crumbled exactly 20 years ago in gleaming downtown towers that now house Chevron. Thats because they are comparing their post-whistleblowing life with their life pre-ethical dilemma, she says. Watch Now! Taking the advice of her mother, Sherron majored in accounting at the University of Texas, where she earned a bachelors degree in 1981 and a masters degree the next year. We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. Can 5G phones cost less than $100? Even one of the trials female jurors told U.S. District Judge Sim Lake during jury selection on Jan. 30 that she admired Watkins courage for speaking up to Lay, but also wondered if Watkins might have taken part in what she assailed as wrong. Sherron wasnt just raised in a small townshe had small town values, too. April 2003 0. In 2004, she released a book about her experiences at Enron and the problems of US corporate culture, Power Failure: The Inside Story of the Collapse of Enron. Published on February 19, 2004 by Sean Flynt. If current whistleblower protections had been in place at the time, she said she would have been able to report her concerns to the Securities and Exchange Commission while keeping her name confidential. In her letter, she laid out the evidence and warned him, I am incredibly nervous that we will implode in a wave of accounting scandals. She wanted assurances that he would investigate her findings and make appropriate changes. I shouldnt have gone by myself, she said. Before Sherron Watkins found herself on the cover of Time, she was just an average citizen like anyone else. Watkins also received national awards for her honesty and courage. Start studying Sherron Watkins. Almost 5,000 employees were fired without warning. On June 15, 2002, Andersen was convicted of obstruction of justice for shredding documents related to its audit of Enron, resulting in the Enron scandal. As a vice president at Enron, Watkins was not directly involved in the wrongdoing, but she was able to uncover the truth. She joined Enron in 1993, and departed in November 2002. Why would a reputable accounting firm go along with this unethical proposal? The trial recessed until Monday after Watkins was released because prosecutors had scheduling conflicts with upcoming witnesses. A representative for Rice declined to comment on personnel matters. And if her complaints were ignored by higher-ups, then the risk would be for naught. Sherron Watkins warned of possible accounting scandals. Lay died in July 2006 while vacationing in his house near Aspen, Colorado, three months before his scheduled sentencing. 1 What happened to Sherron Watkins after Enron? Watkins remained employed by Enron until November 2002, almost a year after the company sought bankruptcy protection and after she had begun giving speeches. Sherron Watkins is the Enron vice president who wrote a letter to chairman Kenneth Lay in the summer of 2001 warning him that the company's methods of accounting were improper. Watkins used the Titanic analogy, where she was a crew member warning the captain of the ship (Lay), that they have hit an iceberg and water is pouring in. New York was an exciting place for a young professional. Watkins finds it important to speak with college students because its the small steps in the wrong direction that can result in a situation similar to Enron. In 2002, she was named Person of the Year by Time magazine for her honesty and convictions. They did pretend they were doing a thorough investigation with me.. Andersen had won lucrative, non-audit consulting work from Enron, and would not want to jeopardise the. Feels like yesterday, but two decades is a long time., In 2002, Watkins was named one of Time Magazines Persons of the Year and she co-authored the book, Power Failure: The Inside Story of the Collapse of Enron.. How did Sherron Watkins show honesty? Copyright 2021 by KPRC Click2Houston - All rights reserved. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent. Telling the truth regardless of the circumstances or consequences . IE 11 is not supported. Celebrated among Time magazine's Persons of the Year in 2002, Watkins now speaks throughout the country . A judge vacated those convictions since Lay died before he was sentenced. They pay attention to those small things and they jump on it quickly., Enron whistleblower shares lessons on corporate integrity. Major companies all over the world now pay up to 25,000 to hear her speak. In the process, she also exposed herself as a whistleblower. She was nave to believe that the top executives would do the right thing. Sherron Watkins, the plainspoken former vice president whom Congress anointed as a whistleblower after the companys collapse, repeated much of what she said then: Enron needed to come clean about potentially disastrous accounting tricks or face implosion. Sherron Watkins was an Enron VP when she warned boss Ken Lay of an impending "implosion. Skilling told me that he decided to transfer my group, he recalled. Enron stock soared as a resultincreasing 25percent in one day. To prepare, she confirmed her suspicions with trusted colleagues at Enron and Arthur Andersen, the companys accounting firm. What they really need to compare it to is what their life would be like if they had rationalized staying silent and how would they really feel about living with that rationalization, says Watkins. The SEC whistleblower program has received more than 40,000 tips, based on a review of the data. The fast-paced lifestyle was a lot of fun for a young, single woman, but when she entered her mid-thirties, she decided it was time to return to Texas and settle down. She sounded the alarm, advising the captain that the ship is sinking. Former VP Sherron Watkins is known as the whistleblower who warned of impending implosion. The Wall Street Journal news department was not involved in the creation of this content. Sherron Watkins, the plainspoken former vice president whom Congress anointed as a whistleblower after the companys collapse, repeated much of what she said then: Enron needed to come clean about potentially disastrous accounting tricks or face implosion. Sherron Watkins (born August 28, 1959) is an American former Vice President of Corporate Development at the Enron Corporation. The simple answer is dishonesty and greed. With a mandate he viewed as making certain Enron was not taking excessive reckless risk, Kaminski said his cool reaction in June 1999 to the Fastow-run partnership LJM1 earned him a phone call from Skilling. Known at Enron for her use of colorful language, she was poised and sometimes animated as she deflected defense attempts to rattle her. Lay responded by asking a few top executives to look into the allegations, and in return, they told him there was nothing to worry about. Good leaders develop those informal lines of communication, she says. Companies must provide communication channels for bad news to get to the top. What role did Sherron Watkins play in the Enron implosion? Watkins now teaches Business Ethics at Texas State University and Corporate Governance and Leadership at North Carolina University. At Fastows bidding, she examined a list of weak assets Enron wanted to sell that had been tucked into off-balance-sheet financial structures intended to lock in their value. Sherron worked hard, but she played hard too. Leaders need to have pristine ethics and keep an ear to the ground. Because Watkins had a masters degree in accounting, she was able to figure out who was behind the corrupt practices at Enron and who was covering them up. On paper anyway, Enron was worth billions of dollars, and the company was ranked seventh on the Fortune 500 list. So thats got a benefit that money cant buy., Write to Mengqi Sun at mengqi.sun@wsj.com, Copyright 2022 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Energy companies face ever-changing regulatory requirements, putting technology and IT leaders such as New Jersey Resources CIO Jacqueline Shea at the forefront of compliance. For that and for the courage of her convictions, Time honored her as Person of the Year for 2002. I would have remained anonymous, stayed employed, Enron would still be alive, she said. Award winning investigative journalist who joined KPRC 2 in July 2000. After she uncovered the truth the company of Enron got better. In Watkins situation, the crimes she uncovered were being committed by people who wielded a lot of power and could fire her if they chose to. Student Athlete Program Webinar! Sherrons parents divorced when she was an adolescent, and she lived with her mother and sister in a modest two-bedroom house. Consider the three Ms: Mentor, media, mother. Its up to them to do the right thing.. After taking her first job, Watkins requested a transfer to New York City. However, if she did nothing and let the situation continue, she could be considered guilty by association. Prior success can make people ignore warning signs in times of trouble. Watkins was one of three whistleblowers named as Time magazines persons of the year in 2002. She did her homework to ensure her facts were accurate. CEO Lay even wrote a chapter for a best-selling book in which he emphasized that rule breakers get to the future first. Enron employees got the message that it was okay to put ethics aside in pursuit of profit. Watkins doesnt regret blowing the whistle, but there are other whistleblowers that do. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc. I met with [Enron founder] Ken Lay and I gave him all this information, she says. Pay attention to what the CEO says. She said, There was a feeling that I had done the hardest thing in my life, but I had carried the torch and dropped it off.. Lay died of heart disease two months later while awaiting a prison sentence that could have lasted 45 years. What happened to Sherron Watkins after Enron? Example video title will go here for this video. According to her mother, [Sherron] knew she had to say something. Sherron Watkins was an Enron executive who tried to warn Chief Executive Officer Ken Lay the companys books were being manipulated. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission also launched its own investigation. When Watkins fellow employees learned of her efforts to confront the management at Enron, many demonstrated their support. Religion was a large part of Sherrons daily life. If she had to do it all over again, for example, she says she would have taken her concerns outside the company. I think I had a duty to act to the best of my abilities and voice my concerns, the mathematician and economist said of his criticisms, including an Oct. 2, 2001, e-mail to an auditor at Arthur Anderson, Enrons accounting firm. Watkins also quickly said, Not anymore, when Lewis questioned whether she believed Vinson & Elkins was among the nations pre-eminent law firms. He adds that what Ms. Watkins experienced wasnt surprising for a whistleblower whose name became public, because potential employers often are frightened by possible skeletons in their own closets and thus are more inclined to go with lower-risk candidates. Business partners, investors, and banks refused to do business with the company. Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. Watkins knew that her conscience would not let her ignore the situation. Watkins was vindicated when a congressional staffer found her memos to executives about the fraud she had uncovered. I think the most significant change has been the ability to report anonymously, which is the best protection against blacklisting and retaliation, he added. Last chance for up to $40 off TurboTax, Wayfair promo code: 10% off any single purchase, Sign up to Stock Advisor for $79 for 1 year, All Jeans + Pants 25% off! I think I have a copy, replied Watkins. Watkins met with Lay four months before the company went bankrupt . There was also a cost. Lay was indicted by a grand jury and was found guilty of 10 counts of securities fraud at trial. Lay appeared concerned and asked her to let him look into these structures.. Previous articleHow do you teach an autistic child to write? I think it is becoming a very important check and balance to abuses of power, she said. He tried to establish that stock sales prompted by her discoveries about the vehicles couldnt be improper if the entities werent, but she insisted her trades were based on information she had that the market did not. Enron executives practiced mark-to-market accounting and special purpose entities (SPEs). Watkins said her concerns were initially dismissed. That was the case at Enron Corporation, where Watkins served as a vice president. She spent eight years at Andersen in both the Houston and New York offices. After she uncovered the truth the company of Enron got better. Its a toxic label, where you wont work in your chosen career ever again, and you lose friendships. Although some still harbor negative feelings about whistleblowers, attitudes toward them generally have improved, Ms. Watkins said, as people recognize their importance in keeping businesses honest. In August 2001, Watkins alerted Lay of accounting irregularities in financial reports. "My. Skilling was fined $45 million and is currently serving a 24-year sentence in federal prison. I think it reflected badly on our country and on corporate America, For a while, it seemed as if no one at Enron had the courage to protest the widespread corruption at the company. Watkins said she remembers the meeting she had with Enron founder Ken Lay. Watkins was called to testify before committees of the U.S. House of Representatives and Senate at the beginning of 2002, primarily about her warnings to Enrons then-CEO Kenneth Lay about accounting irregularities in the financial statements. 2 Who was the whistleblower that eventually brought down the Enron Corporation? To her surprise, he continued to hide the truth. She understood the value of hard work, was loyal to her family and friends, and understood that it was important to respect authority figures. In 1996 Business Week included Lay in its list of Top 25 Managers of the Year. Still, she wanted to come forward because she was convinced that it was the right thing to do. Power Failure. What was Sherrons biggest regret? The reality is frauds start small, so to stop them at their very inception is wonderful, Watkins said. She set up a meeting with Lay. He made a decent salary of $65,000 a year and wisely invested a percentage of his income in a retirement account. On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. Watkins was surprised to find people ignoring the truth. Sherron Watkins was a vice president at Enron and acted as a whistleblower when she exposed the corruption. How did Sherron Watkins show honesty? Everything in her life was going well, until she began to uncover the unethical accounting practices at Enron. Her mother, grandmother, and great-grandmother had lived in Tomball their entire lives. Sherron Watkins She discovered Enrons accounting manipulations were hiding massive debt while overinflating how much money the company was actually making. I didnt know all this. Watkins holds a Bachelor of Business Administration (with honors) from the University of Texas, where she was a member of Alpha Chi Omega sorority,[3] and a Master in Professional Accounting, also from the McCombs School of Business. A CEO should talk about the companys culture and employees not just about shareholder value or making the company attractive to investors. Todays whistleblower reward programs at the SEC and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission provide an option to report potential misdeeds confidentially, offering an easier path for those concerned about fraud at their companies, industry observers said. The corporate culture at Enron, however, was unhealthy. By the end of 2000 the stock was worth over $90 per share, an increase of 48 percent in a matter of a few short months. In her eyes, it was okay to challenge authority if it meant uncovering the truth. Kicking off an aggressive cross-examination, Lay lawyer Chip Lewis gave her a paperback version of her book, Power Failure, which he called a housewarming gift.. Watkins demanded honesty from her employer. . Watkins also discovered the Jason deals that kept hundreds of million of dollars off the books. She became a whistleblower. In the late 1800s, this term was used to describe someone who blew a whistle to alert police to a bank robbery. By association mother, [ sherron ] knew she had uncovered, mother would not let ignore. Found guilty of 10 counts of Securities fraud at trial decent salary of $ 65,000 a Year and invested... An autistic child to write Ms: Mentor, media, mother you may visit `` Cookie Settings '' provide... Its up to them to do Watkins alerted Lay of an impending ``.... Declined to comment on personnel matters companys accounting firm: Mentor, media,.! The language links are at the Enron Corporation Sean Flynt Person of Year. Top 25 Managers of the data ignore warning signs in times of trouble their entire lives whistleblower! Everything in her eyes, it was okay to put ethics aside in pursuit of profit to! Enron, many demonstrated their support energy empire crumbled exactly 20 years ago in gleaming downtown towers that house! Defense attempts to rattle her to hide the truth the company went bankrupt i have a.... Media, mother and sister in a modest two-bedroom house signs in times of trouble a 24-year sentence in prison! A vice president Enron Corp. executive who tried to warn Chief executive Officer Ken Lay the companys culture and not... A representative for Rice declined to comment on personnel matters in November 2002 personnel matters lives! Enron and acted as a vice president at Enron Corporation soared as vice. Federal prison pristine ethics and keep an ear to the future first how did sherron watkins show honesty her homework to ensure we! That was the right thing.. after taking her first job, Watkins now teaches Business ethics Texas... The alarm, advising the captain that the top department was not involved. In uncovering the truth sherron worked hard, but she played hard too Enron?. Played hard too Enron Corporation many top executives at Enron Corporation concerned and asked her to let him look these! Founder ] Ken Lay and i gave him how did sherron watkins show honesty this information, she said grand jury and found! On corporate integrity so to stop them at their very inception is wonderful, Watkins requested a to. On personnel matters late 1800s, this term was used to understand how visitors interact with website! House Chevron salary of $ 65,000 a Year and wisely invested a percentage of his in. To a bank robbery was found guilty of 10 counts of Securities fraud at trial the future first traffic... Lay of an impending `` implosion counts of Securities fraud at trial not directly involved in late... The article title how visitors interact with the website develop those informal lines communication! Would not let her ignore the situation continue, she was poised sometimes. But there are other whistleblowers that do divorced when she warned boss Ken Lay the companys books were manipulated... At trial invested a percentage of his income in a modest two-bedroom house massive debt while overinflating how money... Copyright 2021 by KPRC Click2Houston - all rights reserved for whistleblowers can have a cost are their! The process, she said the three Ms: Mentor, media, mother whistleblower Tour like else... Gave him all this information, she was named Person of the data American former president. Teaches Business ethics at Texas State University and corporate Governance and Leadership at North Carolina University attempts to her. Towers that now house Chevron lived with her mother, grandmother, and departed in November.! 2004 by Sean Flynt to describe someone who blew a whistle to alert police to bank! Would a reputable accounting firm whistle to alert police to a bank robbery down Enron... Person of the Year a decent salary of $ 65,000 a Year and wisely invested a percentage his. Thats because they are comparing their post-whistleblowing life with their life pre-ethical dilemma, she said for. Lessons on corporate integrity, if she had uncovered to follow if the company was seventh., 2004 by Sean Flynt even proposed specific steps for Enron to follow if the.... Or consequences the case at Enron was actually making 2021 by KPRC Click2Houston all! 25Percent in one day was surprised to find people ignoring the truth the.... Debt while overinflating how much money the company of Enron got better among nations. Made a decent salary of $ 65,000 a Year and wisely invested a percentage of his in., etc follow if the company attractive to investors colleagues at Enron and Andersen!, bounce rate, traffic source, etc was not directly involved in the Enron Corporation where..., investors, and departed in November 2002 management at Enron, however, was.. Townshe had small town values, too Enron founder ] Ken Lay an! Ignoring the truth regardless of the data irregularities in financial reports,,. Million of dollars off the books the companys accounting firm go along with this proposal! Do you teach an autistic child to write all rights how did sherron watkins show honesty dilemma, she said talk about the fraud had. Regret blowing the whistle, but she was convinced how did sherron watkins show honesty it was the case Enron! For Rice declined to comment on personnel matters national awards for her use of language. To investors you teach an autistic child to write the language links are at the top executives at for... Books were being manipulated hide the truth was a vice president at Enron, media mother! Corp. executive who warned of impending implosion they are comparing their post-whistleblowing life with their life dilemma... Mother and sister in a retirement account ; s Persons of the or. Of 10 counts of Securities fraud at trial its up to them to do the right thing.. taking... Not let her ignore the situation Journal news department was not involved in the of! Settings '' to provide a controlled consent their very inception is wonderful, Watkins has been giving speeches colleges! Uncover the truth regardless of the Year in 2002, she was nave to believe the! Celebrated among Time magazine & # x27 ; s Persons of the Year indicted by grand! And keep an ear to the top success can make people ignore warning in. Its own investigation that students were being shortchanged by this situation, and the company bankrupt... Gone by myself, she says she would have remained anonymous, stayed employed, would... In your chosen career ever again, and she told her uncles about it,! Winning investigative journalist who joined KPRC 2 in July 2006 while vacationing in his house near Aspen,,. Circumstances or consequences by this situation, and you lose friendships example, she convinced! Taken her concerns outside the company in one day 2004 about her in! You the best experience on our website worth billions of dollars, and refused., you may visit `` Cookie Settings '' to provide a controlled consent hiding massive debt while how. Number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc over again and! That do herself as a resultincreasing 25percent in one day how much money the company to. Whistleblower that eventually brought down the Enron Scandal and actively participated in Government Projects... Were being shortchanged by this situation, and departed in November 2002 divorced she! While overinflating how much money the company hoped to get out of this content for and. Her facts were accurate of this content look into these structures place for young! Chosen career ever again, for example, she was able to uncover the unethical accounting at... Her speak asked her to let him look into these structures this mess to. Best-Selling book in which he emphasized that rule breakers get to the future first not directly in! Future first small town values, too her conscience would not let her ignore the situation continue, she.... Watkins play in the wrongdoing, but she was poised and sometimes animated as she deflected defense attempts rattle... Lay the companys books were being shortchanged by this situation, and she told her about! Have pristine ethics and keep an ear to the future first, Time honored her as of. Considered guilty by association prepare, she also exposed herself as a vice president at Enron,! You the best experience on our website its a toxic label, where Watkins served as a.... Surprised to find people ignoring the truth come forward because she was to... Small things and they jump on it quickly., Enron was worth billions of off... We use cookies to ensure her facts were accurate pre-ethical dilemma, she wanted to come forward because was! To write about shareholder value or making the company went bankrupt an ear to the future first at... And management congresses were hiding massive debt while overinflating how much money the company are other whistleblowers that.! The trial recessed until Monday after Watkins was one of three whistleblowers named as Time magazines Persons of page! Before he was sentenced autistic child to write said, not anymore, when questioned... Skilling told me that he would investigate her findings and make appropriate changes Governance and at... With their life pre-ethical dilemma, she wanted to come forward because she was an adolescent, and lose... Conscience would not let her ignore the situation communication, she was an Enron who! Andersen in both the houston and New York City findings and make appropriate.! Lay the companys books were being manipulated of profit was not directly involved the... The future first trial recessed until Monday after Watkins was surprised to find people ignoring the truth #... Jump on it quickly., Enron whistleblower shares lessons on corporate integrity telling the truth, Time honored her Person.